Pausanias Analysis

Sentence-level words and phrases that predict skepticism vs. non-skepticism

Model Performance Metrics

The following metrics are from the logistic regression classifier's performance on the test set:

Class Precision Recall F1-Score Support
Non-skeptical 0.891 0.733 0.805 986
Skeptical 0.226 0.467 0.305 165
Overall Accuracy 0.695 1151

Sentence Predictors of Skeptical Content

Sort by:
Word/Phrase English Coefficient Skeptical Count Non-skeptical Count p-value q-value
εἴτε whether 3.1430 14 3 9.5e-10 3.17e-07
ὡσ as; like; how; that; when 3.0436 135 433 2.17e-09 5.42e-07
ὑπό under; by (of agent) 2.5023 111 348 2.9e-08 4.83e-06
οὐ not 2.4651 180 618 2.24e-10 1.12e-07
μεγαρεύσ a Megarian 2.4446 19 31 5.27e-05 0.00273
αὐτόσ self; he/she/it; the same (with the article) 2.3666 258 1183 0.000149 0.00708
εἰκόσ likely; probable; reasonable 2.2404 15 16 9.14e-06 0.000653
πρῶτοσ first 2.1459 50 141 3.1e-05 0.00182
οὗτοσ this (man) 2.0700 285 1089 4.66e-12 4.66e-09
οὐδέν nothing 2.0689 21 51 0.00171 0.0407
τίθημι to put, place, set; establish; appoint 1.9098 31 63 8.14e-06 0.000653
γίγνομαι καί I become, and 1.8683 12 17 0.000512 0.0171
λόγοσ word; speech; account; reason; argument 1.8445 56 152 3.81e-06 0.000381
δείκνυμι to show, point out 1.8412 9 17 0.0118 0.135
κομίζω I bring, carry, convey 1.7849 23 52 0.000448 0.0155
ἥρωσ hero 1.7612 15 39 0.0136 0.149
ὄνομα name 1.7587 59 136 2.16e-08 4.33e-06
σαφήσ clear 1.7490 8 9 0.00156 0.0381
φαίνω to bring to light; to show; to reveal 1.7335 20 52 0.00431 0.0777
δῶρον gift 1.7219 10 13 0.000929 0.0258
ἄιδω I sing 1.6721 8 15 0.017 0.167
δράκων serpent; dragon 1.6702 10 17 0.00435 0.0777
εἰ if 1.6588 34 65 9.84e-07 0.000141
καί οὗτοσ and this man 1.6265 52 141 8.54e-06 0.000653
γίγνομαι I become; am born; happen 1.6217 111 402 1.26e-05 0.000841
δέ ἄν but/and; ἄν is a modal particle indicating potentiality (“would/might”) 1.6009 14 12 3.31e-06 0.000381
ἀνήρ man 1.5746 72 276 0.00218 0.0507
αἰτία cause; reason; blame/responsibility; accusation/charge 1.5687 12 29 0.0176 0.171
τίκτω to beget, give birth to; bring forth, produce 1.5660 10 25 0.0362 0.262
ποσειδῶν Poseidon 1.5586 22 72 0.0261 0.225

Sentence Predictors of Non-skeptical Content

Sort by:
Word/Phrase English Coefficient Skeptical Count Non-skeptical Count p-value q-value
ἵστημι to set, make stand; establish; stop; (intrans.) stand -1.9910 4 79 0.00733 0.11
ἕκαστοσ each -1.9119 1 71 0.000295 0.0113
μοῖρα fate, destiny; share, portion -1.7301 1 44 0.0105 0.129
βωμόσ altar -1.6786 5 98 0.00113 0.0305
καί παῖσ and a child -1.5724 6 66 0.0955 0.435
δηλόω to make clear; to show; to reveal; to indicate -1.5596 5 67 0.0386 0.263
γίγνομαι δέ and I become -1.5504 4 48 0.172 0.562
ἄξιοσ worthy; deserving -1.5394 2 72 0.00137 0.035
ἀλλήλων of one another -1.5313 1 35 0.0347 0.261
ἑαυτοῦ of himself/itself; his/its own -1.4388 9 85 0.13 0.507
χείρ hand -1.3893 1 52 0.00317 0.0673
καταλαμβάνω to seize, overtake, catch; grasp, understand -1.3785 0 35 0.00679 0.108
μέλλω be about to, intend (to) -1.3459 3 66 0.00977 0.128
τε and -1.3331 154 1101 0.00391 0.0761
ἀριθμόσ number -1.2845 4 47 0.231 0.662
ἀριστόδημοσ Aristodemus -1.2805 2 29 0.306 0.702
ἀποστέλλω I send out -1.2763 1 48 0.00722 0.11
αἱρέω to take; seize; (middle) choose -1.2472 9 103 0.0284 0.233
οὗτοσ δέ this one, however -1.2375 21 102 0.478 0.836
ἅμα at the same time; together (with) -1.2353 2 35 0.158 0.545
ἐναντίοσ opposite; contrary; hostile -1.2264 1 35 0.0347 0.261
γραφή writing; (in Athenian law) public indictment -1.2238 1 54 0.0033 0.0673
δέ ἔτι and yet -1.2136 2 25 0.415 0.798
ἔχω I have -1.2039 78 495 0.402 0.798
ἄκροσ topmost -1.1913 0 33 0.0109 0.13
πυθία Pythia -1.1732 4 24 1 1
τρίπουσ tripod -1.1625 1 24 0.162 0.545
καί παρά and beside/at/from/to/along/contrary to -1.1452 1 37 0.0355 0.262
μετά δέ and afterwards -1.1404 4 61 0.0518 0.321
ἀφίστημι to cause to revolt or remove; (intrans./middle) to revolt, fall away, withdraw, depart -1.1400 0 28 0.0272 0.226

Simplified Checklist Version

This reduced model keeps only the words or phrases with q-value below 0.1, then turns them into a simple checklist.

Start at -0.89 points. If one of the items below appears at least once, add its points once. If the final score ends above 0, classify the text as Skeptical. That is the same as saying the listed word-points must add up past +0.89.

Full logistic model: 69.5% | Simplified checklist: 69.0% | Always guess Non-skeptical: 85.7%

This shorter model uses 61 statistically strong vocabulary items.

These confusion matrices show which texts each approach gets right and where it makes false alarms or misses.

Full Logistic Model

Predicted
Non-skeptical Skeptical
Actual Non-skeptical 723 263
Skeptical 88 77

Simplified Checklist

Predicted
Non-skeptical Skeptical
Actual Non-skeptical 706 280
Skeptical 77 88

Always Guess Non-skeptical

Predicted
Non-skeptical Skeptical
Actual Non-skeptical 986 0
Skeptical 165 0
Word/Phrase English Points If Seen Pushes Toward q-value
χείρ hand -5.23 Non-skeptical 0.0673
οὐ μήν not, however +4.19 Skeptical 0.000381
εἴτε whether +3.72 Skeptical 3.17e-07
μήν month; indeed, surely -2.25 Non-skeptical 0.0113
ἕκαστοσ each -2.22 Non-skeptical 0.0113
κρήτη Crete +1.90 Skeptical 0.0321
εἰκόσ likely; probable; reasonable +1.61 Skeptical 0.000653
δῶρον gift +1.59 Skeptical 0.0258
γραφή writing; (in Athenian law) public indictment -1.47 Non-skeptical 0.0673
δράκων serpent; dragon +1.46 Skeptical 0.0777
ὡσ καί just as +1.45 Skeptical 0.0923
γίγνομαι καί I become, and +1.44 Skeptical 0.0171
ἄξιοσ worthy; deserving -1.44 Non-skeptical 0.035
σαφήσ clear +1.40 Skeptical 0.0381
δέ ἄν but/and; ἄν is a modal particle indicating potentiality (“would/might”) +1.32 Skeptical 0.000381
πέλοψ Pelops +1.29 Skeptical 0.0258
μεγαρεύσ a Megarian +1.23 Skeptical 0.00273
ὁμολογέω to agree, admit, or confess +1.18 Skeptical 0.00155
δόξα opinion +1.09 Skeptical 0.0761
κομίζω I bring, carry, convey +1.04 Skeptical 0.0155
οὐδέν nothing +1.04 Skeptical 0.0407
πρῶτοσ first +0.96 Skeptical 0.00182
εἰκάζω to liken; to conjecture, infer, guess +0.93 Skeptical 0.0923
τίθημι to put, place, set; establish; appoint +0.93 Skeptical 0.000653
βωμόσ altar -0.87 Non-skeptical 0.0305
δέ ὄνομα but a name +0.84 Skeptical 0.0155
ἀλκάθουσ Alcathous +0.82 Skeptical 0.0768
νεκρόσ dead; corpse +0.78 Skeptical 0.00251
λόγοσ word; speech; account; reason; argument +0.77 Skeptical 0.000381
οὐδείσ no one +0.75 Skeptical 0.0552
ὀνομάζω to name; to call; to mention +0.67 Skeptical 0.0113
ὑπό under; by (of agent) +0.65 Skeptical 4.83e-06
καί οὗτοσ and this man +0.62 Skeptical 0.000653
μήτηρ mother +0.62 Skeptical 0.0761
εἰ if +0.59 Skeptical 0.000141
μετά with (when followed by the genitive); after (when followed by the accusative) -0.58 Non-skeptical 0.0997
ἐπεί when, after, since +0.57 Skeptical 0.0799
καί ὡσ and as +0.54 Skeptical 0.0217
δέ οὐ but not +0.53 Skeptical 0.0113
φαίνω to bring to light; to show; to reveal +0.53 Skeptical 0.0777
ὄνομα name +0.52 Skeptical 4.33e-06
εἴην I would be; may I be +0.47 Skeptical 0.0113
ὡσ as; like; how; that; when +0.46 Skeptical 5.42e-07
παῖσ child +0.44 Skeptical 0.0155
γῆ earth, land +0.44 Skeptical 0.0777
αὐτόσ self; he/she/it; the same (with the article) +0.42 Skeptical 0.00708
τε and -0.41 Non-skeptical 0.0761
ἔτοσ year -0.41 Non-skeptical 0.0997
ἀνήρ man +0.40 Skeptical 0.0507
ὄνομα ἀπό name from +0.39 Skeptical 0.0223
οὐ not +0.38 Skeptical 1.12e-07
μέν οὐ indeed not +0.37 Skeptical 0.0223
οὗτοσ this (man) +0.37 Skeptical 4.66e-09
ἄν would; might; could; -ever (as in whoever/whenever) +0.36 Skeptical 0.000653
θυγάτηρ daughter +0.35 Skeptical 0.0179
εἰ δέ but if +0.28 Skeptical 0.00273
ὅστισ whoever +0.25 Skeptical 0.0673
γε at least +0.24 Skeptical 0.0673
τισ someone, anyone; a certain (one) +0.19 Skeptical 0.0376
γίγνομαι I become; am born; happen +0.17 Skeptical 0.000841
ἀπό from, away from +0.15 Skeptical 0.0664